(VIDEOS) Ellison Mourns Americans Killed in Libya, Condemns Video That Sparked Attacks

The representative called the video "amateurish and stupid," said protesters "could have written letters."

U.S. Rep. Keith Ellison (D-MN) on Wednesday said he mourns for the Americans killed during riots at American diplomatic missions in the Middle East, and he condemned the video that sparked the protests.

Speaking on the floor of the U.S. House of Representatives Wednesday morning, Ellison said he is "deeply disturbed,"  termed the attacks a "terrible, terrible tragedy" and said protesters "could have written letters and could have registered their disapproval in a number of ways, but they resorted to murder."

Four Americans, including U.S. Ambassador to Libya Chris Stevens, were killed Tuesday during attacks on the American Consulate in Benghazi, Libya. Violence also erupted at the U.S. Embassy in Cairo, in response to a short American-made video called "Innocence of Muslims" that mocks Islam's founding prophet, Muhammad.

(See Ellison's short speech Wednesday on the floor of the U.S. House above. You can watch a clip from the movie that sparked the attacks by clicking on the second YouTube thumbnail. NOTE: The footage may be considered offensive.) 

Ellison released the following statement:

I am deeply disturbed by the attacks on our diplomatic missions in Libya and Egypt. Four Americans have now been killed, including U.S. Ambassador to Libya Chris Stevens. My heart goes out to their families. They were brave public servants working tirelessly to improve relations with Egypt, Libya, and the rest of the world. This is a tragic loss. 

The amateurish and stupid video that sparked these riots was deeply offensive not only to Muslims but also to anyone who respects the faith of others. It was designed to provoke, and sadly, the provocateurs successfully induced some people to take the bait. Instead of ignoring or peacefully condemning the film, they resorted to violence and mayhem.

Yes, the film’s creators hatefully attacked what so many people hold most dear: their relationship with the Divine. But responding with violence is never justified. And those who think they are doing so in the name of Islam are wrong and ill informed. The abuse of free speech rights, no matter how offensive, does not give license for senseless acts of violence.

People need to understand that the United States government had no role in creating this film. In fact, the government has condemned it and the American people have rejected it; it violates the American value of religious tolerance. The vast majority of Christians, Muslims, Jews and people of other faiths live in peace and harmony in the United States, and reject the hateful expressions in the film. No one should confuse the tiny group who made thisdisrespectful and deliberately provocative film with the American people or the U.S. government. The United States Constitution protects religious freedom, but it also prohibits the government from silencing misguided individuals who abuse their free speech rights.

Hateful provocateurs will always try to stir the pot, but it’s up to us to remain calm and not let it boil over. Now innocent public servants who dedicated their lives to building bridges between people are dead. What we need is more understanding and tolerance, not conflict and bloodshed.

Ellison's Republican opponent, Chris Fields, released the following response:

Today I join with many Americans who mourn the savage murder of four innocent American diplomats who lost their life, including U.S. Ambassador, J. Christopher Stevens, in the attack on our embassy at Benghazi, Libya.

I join Congressman Ellison’s condemnation of the attacks. I do not however share his view that the attackers were provoked by a “stupid video.” Intolerance of American values provoked these brutal murders. 

Many people thought that the election of the first Muslim to Congress would show the Islamic world that America was not only a free country, but a tolerant one as well. They hoped that Congressman Ellison would enhance the efforts of our country to reach out to the Islamic world. His shocking statement on this matter sadly indicates that he believes American values were the chief instigator of this violent attack. Such a statement is shameful and disgraceful.

It's an outrage that a sitting U.S. Congressman would try to convince Americans that our values and constitution provoked the murders of those who served our country.

I believe we must work with Libyan officials to ensure these murderers are brought to justice. We must also work to ensure the safety of those who serve our country abroad. 

Americans have a constitutional right to free speech. It is long past time that radicals in the Islamic world reconcile themselves to that fact. When they do the world will be a much better place and these senseless acts of violence will no longer occur.

America is a good place and we have no reason to apologize for our values or our constitution. We are a free society and must remain that way. 

Rich Altman September 12, 2012 at 06:32 PM
What we need now is for the Marines to protect our embassies and consulates around the world from anyone attempting to break in. As for Ellison's contention that this was an "abuse of free speech," it is no such thing. Even assuming that the film (which I have not seen) is hateful and disrespectful to Islam, it is protected under OUR laws. You don't need constitutional protection to voice popular sentiments...it is the unpopular ones that need protection. The answer to hate speech is not censorship -- or in this case murder -- but MORE speech. Sadly again, on the anniversary of 9/11 Islamist terrorists murdered four more Americans and invaded two of our sovereign diplomatic outposts. Mindless hatred all because someone offended them. The word for this is INEXCUSABLE Rep. Ellison. You seem to be searching for a way to rationalize or even mitigate these terrorists' actions.
guy davidson September 13, 2012 at 04:02 AM
can I vote for Chris Fields more than once.... there must be a way. Mr. Ellison is not my cup of tea.. although for those of you who like tea - maybe I should not have said that - it could be offensive.
Kent September 13, 2012 at 02:16 PM
It is funny and sad that Mr. Ellison jumped on the movie with no evidence that it was the cause of the riots and murder. Did he forget that the radical Islamic world hates us and our current failed international policy is expanding the problem? It is the radical Islamic religion that believes it must murder anyone who disagrees with its teachings. IF this attack was about the movie then the attackers are very unintelligent. More people will view the movie to see how it could spark the attack then if it was ignored. In fact for Mr. Ellison to even discuss the movie increased its viewership. I suspect the attack had more to do with revenge for the USA killing terrorists. Terrorists who no matter what we do as a nation will try to kill us.
Ezra Pound September 13, 2012 at 02:53 PM
Dear Guy Davidson: Voting more than once with the Republican cry for voter ID would not allow you to vote for Mr, "I don't write good checks" Fields.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »